1937-D Buffalo nickel 'Three-Legged' Buffalo nickel value
A problem-free 1937-D Buffalo nickel 'Three-Legged' Buffalo nickel is worth about VF-20 $1,147, XF-40 $1,567, AU-50 $2,160, MS-63 $5,719, MS-65 $11,600, from VERA by Variety Errors (updated November 11, 2026).
Ungraded estimate: $566–$989
Ungraded estimate: a typical circulated example. Only an estimate; condition changes the value a lot. (G-4 to F-12)
| Grade | Value |
|---|---|
| VF-20 Very Fine | $1,147 |
| XF-40 Extremely Fine | $1,567 |
| AU-50 About Uncirculated | $2,160 |
| MS-63 Choice Uncirculated | $5,719 |
| MS-65 Gem Uncirculated | $11,600 |
About this coin
No new sale was verified for this row in this review, so ranges are deliberately wide.
Genuine pieces show a line of raised 'droplets' under the belly, a weak rear hoof and a polished-away front leg; tooled-off legs on normal 1937-D nickels leave scraped fields. Also check 1936-D 3½-leg (different variety).
Where these values come from
VERA sets a coin's value from verified sales at that grade where they exist (graded coins sold at auction, PCGS prices, VERA's nightly research), and from the Variety Errors price chart for this series where they do not. Values are for problem-free coins. A valuable coin should be checked against recent sold results, and certified.
Coin values · Banknote values · Values are research values from VERA, not an offer to buy or sell and not an appraisal. © VarietyErrors.